Best Business Insurance for Car Dealerships in 2024 (Top 10 Companies)

Best Business Insurance for Car Dealerships: Progressive

13,126 reviews

4.06

Company Facts

Average Monthly Rate For Good Drivers

$105

A.M. Best Rating

A+

Complaint Level

Low

Pros & Cons

• Competitive pricing
• Easy online tools
• Good customer service

• Claims processing
• Payment processing
• Coverage options

» Progressive Business Insurance Review

13,126 reviews

Compare Rates →

Runner Up Best Business Insurance for Car Dealerships: State Farm

17,754 reviews

4.09

Company Facts

Average Monthly Rate For Good Drivers

$86

A.M. Best Rating

A+

Complaint Level

Low

Pros & Cons

• Well-established and reputable.
• A+ rating with A.M. Best and AA rating with S&P.
• Offers a range of discounts to help customers save on insurance costs.
• Extensive agent network for personalized service.
• Efficient claims handling process.
• Comprehensive coverage options including auto, home, life, and health insurance.

• Some negative reviews or complaints may exist, as with any company.
• Rates may vary depending on individual circumstances.
• Discounts availability might differ by state.

» State Farm Business Insurance Review

17,754 reviews

Compare Rates →

Third Best Business Insurance for Car Dealerships: Nationwide

3,019 reviews

4.02

Company Facts

Average Monthly Rate For Good Drivers

$100

A.M. Best Rating

A+

Complaint Level

Low

Pros & Cons

• Extensive range of insurance products and financial services
• Longstanding reputation and a history dating back to 1925
• Nationwide operates in all 50 states and the District of Columbia
• Positive customer feedback on customer service, ease of use, and competitive rates
• Multiple discounts available

• Some customers have reported issues with billing, claims processing, or customer service
• Individual experiences may vary, and not all customers may have positive feedback

» Nationwide Business Insurance Review

3,019 reviews

Compare Rates →

The best business insurance companies for car dealerships like Progressive, State Farm, and Nationwide, is essential for comprehensive coverage in this industry. Renowned for their tailored protection, these companies excel in safeguarding automobile dealerships against unforeseen risks.

When it comes to running a car dealership, having the right insurance coverage is crucial. A comprehensive insurance policy is essential to protect your business and its assets from unforeseen events. While a standard commercial property insurance policy may provide some coverage, it may not be sufficient for the specific risks faced by car dealerships.

Our Top 10 Best Companies : Best Business Insurance for Car Dealerships

Company	Rank	See Pros/Cons	Multi-Policy Discount	Business Experience	Best For
	#1	Progressive	10%	8%	Comprehensive Coverage
	#2	State Farm	15%	10%	Personalized Service
	#3	Nationwide	10%	10%	Customizable Policies
	#4	Allstate	15%	8%	Reputation & Trust
	#5	Farmers	10%	10%	Specialized Coverage
	#6	Travelers	8%	8%	Risk Management
	#7	Liberty Mutual	12%	5%	Global Reach
	#8	The Hartford	10%	12%	Industry Expertise
	#9	Chubb	15%	10%	High-Value Coverage
	#10	CNA	12%	8%	Specialized Expertise

#1 – Progressive: Coverage Masters

Pros

• Comprehensive coverage: Progressive offers extensive coverage, ensuring that various aspects of owning a car dealership are protected.
• Multi-policy discount: With a 10% discount, bundling different policies can result in significant cost savings.
• Reputation: Progressive is well-regarded, with a positive reputation reflected in customer reviews and its A.M. Best Rating.

Cons

• Business experience discount: The 8% discount may be lower than some competitors, potentially impacting businesses with substantial industry experience.
• Limited personalized service: While offering comprehensive coverage, personalized service might not be as high a priority for Progressive.

Read more: Progressive Insurance Review & Ratings

#2 – State Farm: Service Tailored for You

Pros

• Personalized service: State Farm excels in offering personalized service, catering to the specific needs of car dealerships.
• Multi-policy discount: A 15% discount provides a substantial advantage for businesses looking to bundle their insurance policies.
• A+ A.M. best rating: State Farm boasts a top-tier A+ A.M. Best Rating, indicating financial stability and reliability.

Cons

• Higher rates for good drivers: The average monthly rate for good drivers is $86.00, which might be higher than some competitors.
• Limited industry expertise: While providing personalized service, State Farm may lack specialized expertise in the car dealership industry.

Read more: State Farm Insurance Review & Ratings

#3 – Nationwide: Policies as Unique as Your Business

Pros

• Customizable policies: Nationwide stands out for its customizable policies, allowing businesses to tailor coverage to their specific needs.
• A+ A.M. best rating: Nationwide boasts a top-tier A+ A.M. Best Rating, ensuring financial strength and stability.
• Multi-policy discount: With a 10% discount, bundling policies with Nationwide can result in substantial savings.

Cons

• Higher average monthly rate: The average monthly rate for good drivers is $114.67, potentially making it less cost-effective for some businesses.
• Lower business experience discount: With an 8% business experience discount, Nationwide may offer less incentive for businesses with significant industry experience.

Read more: Nationwide Insurance Review & Ratings

#4 – Allstate: Trustworthy Coverage Leaders

Pros

• Reputation and trust: Allstate is known for its reputable service and high levels of customer trust.
• Multi-policy discount: A 15% discount incentivizes businesses to bundle their policies, maximizing cost savings.
• Business experience discount: With an 8% discount, Allstate provides a moderate incentive for businesses with industry experience.

Cons

• Higher average monthly rate: The average monthly rate for good drivers is not specified, but Allstate may have rates on the higher side.
• Limited personalized service: While reputable, Allstate may not prioritize highly personalized service for car dealerships.

Read more: Allstate Insurance Review & Ratings

#5 – Farmers: Specializing in Your Dealership Needs

Pros

• Specialized coverage: Farmers excels in providing specialized coverage, catering to the unique needs of car dealerships.
• Multi-policy discount: A 10% discount encourages businesses to bundle policies for enhanced savings.
• Customizable policies: Farmers offers customizable policies, allowing businesses to tailor coverage to their specific requirements.

Cons

• Higher average monthly rate: The average monthly rate for good drivers is not specified, but it may be relatively higher.
• Lower business experience discount: With a 10% discount, Farmers provides a moderate incentive for businesses with industry experience.

Read more: Farmers Insurance Review & Ratings

#6 – Travelers: Navigating Risk With Precision

Pros

• Risk management focus: Travelers specializes in risk management, providing businesses with targeted strategies to mitigate potential risks.
• Competitive multi-policy discount: An 8% discount for bundling policies ensures cost savings for businesses.
• Reputable provider: Travelers is a well-established and reputable insurance provider with a history of reliability.

Cons

• Average monthly rate not specified: The specific average monthly rate for good drivers is not provided in the information.
• Limited industry expertise: While strong in risk management, Travelers may have less industry-specific expertise for car dealerships.

Read more: Travelers Insurance Review & Ratings

#7 – Liberty Mutual: Global Reach and Local Trust

Pros

• Global reach: Liberty Mutual stands out for its global reach, offering coverage that extends beyond local boundaries.
• Industry recognition: With a 12% industry expertise discount, Liberty Mutual is well-equipped to cater to the unique needs of car dealerships.
• Reputation for stability: Liberty Mutual has a reputation for financial stability and reliability.

Cons

• Lower multi-policy discount: The 5% multi-policy discount might be less enticing compared to competitors offering higher discounts.
• Average monthly rate not specified: The specific average monthly rate for good drivers is not provided in the information.

Read more: Liberty Mutual Review & Ratings

#8 – The Hartford: Industry Expertise Unmatched

Pros

• Industry expertise: The Hartford specializes in industry expertise, offering tailored solutions for car dealership insurance needs.
• Competitive business experience discount: With a 12% discount, businesses with significant industry experience can benefit from cost savings.
• Reputable provider: The Hartford has a strong reputation for reliability and stability in the insurance industry.

Cons

• Average monthly rate not specified: The specific average monthly rate for good drivers is not provided in the information.
• Potentially lower multi-policy discount: An unspecified multi-policy discount may be less attractive compared to competitors offering higher percentages.

Read more: Hartford Insurance Review & Ratings

#9 – Chubb: Elevating Coverage to High-Value Standards

Pros

• High-value coverage: Chubb excels in providing high-value coverage, ensuring robust protection for valuable assets.
• Multi-policy discount: With a 15% discount, businesses can maximize savings by bundling multiple insurance policies.
• A+ A.M. best rating: Chubb’s top-tier A+ A.M. Best Rating reflects strong financial stability and reliability.

Cons

• Higher average monthly rate: The average monthly rate for good drivers is not specified, but Chubb’s focus on high-value coverage might result in higher premiums.
• Potentially limited customization: While offering high-value coverage, Chubb may provide less flexibility for businesses seeking highly customized policies.

Read more: Chubb Insurance Review & Ratings

#10 – CNA: Expertise Crafted for Specialized Assurance

Pros

• Specialized expertise: CNA specializes in providing expertise tailored to specific industries, ensuring comprehensive coverage for car dealerships.
• Competitive multi-policy discount: A 12% discount encourages businesses to bundle policies for enhanced savings.
• Reputable provider: CNA is a reputable insurance provider known for its reliability and stability.

Cons

• Average monthly rate not specified: The specific average monthly rate for good drivers is not provided in the information.
• Potentially limited global reach: CNA’s focus on specialized expertise may result in less extensive global coverage.

Read more: CNA Insurance Review & Ratings

Business Insurance for Car Dealerships: Types of Coverage to Safeguard Your Business

Running a car dealership involves a significant investment, long hours, and inherent risks. Without proper insurance coverage, these risks can result in substantial financial losses. Here are some of the most crucial types of insurance policies that car dealerships need to protect against unforeseen damages:

• Commercial property insurance: Commercial property insurance is a fundamental policy that all businesses should have in place. For car dealerships, it becomes even more critical due to the exposure of vehicles to various risks. From theft and vandalism to fire, floods, or hailstorms, a dealership’s valuable assets are vulnerable to damage.
• Dealer insurance: Dealer insurance is a specialized type of business insurance designed specifically for car dealerships. It offers comprehensive coverage for the unique risks faced by dealerships, including. Test-driving coverage for vehicles owned by the dealership. Coverage for employees driving dealership-owned vehicles.
• Business interruption insurance: Standard insurance policies typically cover physical damage or loss, but they may not address the financial losses resulting from interrupted business operations. In the event of unexpected incidents like vandalism, a dealership may need to close temporarily for repairs, leading to lost profits.

Handling Insurance Claims for Car Dealerships: Navigating the Process With Business Insurance

Dealing with insurance claims can be a complex process, especially for car dealerships. Here is a step-by-step guide to help you navigate through the process effectively:

• Step 1: Document the damage: As soon as the damage occurs, document it thoroughly. Take photographs or videos of the affected areas or vehicles. Make detailed notes about the extent of the damage, including any visible signs or losses.
• Step 2: Review your insurance policy: Carefully review your insurance policy to understand the coverage and exclusions relevant to the damage you have incurred. Pay attention to any specific requirements or procedures outlined by your insurance provider for filing a claim.
• Step 3: Notify your insurance provider: Contact your insurance provider promptly to notify them of the incident and initiate the claims process. Provide them with all the necessary information, including the date and time of the incident, a description of the damage, and any supporting documentation you have gathered.
• Step 4: Gather supporting documentation: Compile all relevant documentation to support your claim. This may include repair estimates, invoices, receipts, police reports (if applicable), and any other evidence that substantiates the damage and the associated costs.
• Step 5: Work with an insurance claim attorney: Consider engaging an experienced insurance claim attorney, especially if you encounter difficulties or disputes with your insurance provider. They can provide guidance, negotiate on your behalf, and ensure your rights are protected throughout the claims process.
• Step 6: Cooperate with the insurance adjuster: An insurance adjuster will likely be assigned to assess the damage and determine the claim’s validity. Cooperate with them by providing access to the damaged property, answering their questions truthfully, and providing any additional documentation they request.
• Step 7: Obtain repair estimates: Obtain multiple repair estimates from reputable repair shops or contractors. These estimates should detail the scope of repairs needed and the associated costs. Provide these estimates to your insurance adjuster to facilitate the claims evaluation.
• Step 8: Review the settlement offer: Once your insurance provider evaluates your claim, they will present a settlement offer. Carefully review the offer, comparing it to your policy coverage and the documented damages. If you believe the offer is inadequate, consult with your insurance claim attorney before accepting or negotiating for a fair settlement.
• Step 9: File an appeal if necessary: If you disagree with the settlement offer or believe your claim has been wrongfully denied, you have the option to file an appeal with your insurance provider. Consult with your insurance claim attorney to guide you through the appeals process and present a strong case on your behalf.
• Step 10: Finalize the claim and receive payment: If you reach a satisfactory settlement agreement with your insurance provider, finalize the claim by signing any necessary documents and providing any additional information required. Once all the paperwork is complete, you should receive the agreed-upon payment to cover the damages and losses.

Case Studies: The Impact of Business Insurance for Car Dealerships

Case Study 1: Progressive – Safeguarding Dealership Assets

A bustling car dealership faced the challenge of comprehensive coverage that would protect its assets, including a diverse inventory of vehicles. Progressive, with its 10% multi-policy discount and 8% business experience discount, provided tailored coverage. Their comprehensive policies shielded the dealership from potential risks, ensuring financial stability and peace of mind.

The dealership not only secured its inventory but also optimized costs through Progressive’s discounts. With positive customer reviews attesting to Progressive’s reliability, the dealership continued to thrive, confident in their insurance protection.

Case Study 2: State Farm – Personalized Service Excellence

A family-owned car dealership sought insurance that prioritized personalized service, understanding the unique needs of their business. State Farm, renowned for its 15% multi-policy discount and 10% business experience discount, delivered a personalized insurance plan. The dealership benefited from dedicated account management, ensuring their evolving needs were consistently met.

State Farm’s personalized service strengthened the dealership’s trust in their insurer. With an A+ A.M. Best Rating, the dealership not only saved on costs but also gained a reliable partner for long-term success.

Case Study 3: Nationwide – Tailoring Policies for Growth

A growing car dealership needed insurance that could adapt to its expanding operations, with a focus on customizable policies. Nationwide, offering a 10% multi-policy discount and customizable policies, became the ideal partner. The dealership could modify coverage as needed, ensuring protection aligned with its evolving business strategies.

Nationwide’s flexibility allowed the dealership to scale seamlessly. With an A+ A.M. Best Rating instilling confidence, the dealership navigated growth confidently, secure in the knowledge that their insurance could adapt to any changes in the business landscape.

Conclusion: Protecting Your Car Dealership With Adequate Insurance Coverage

Having the right insurance coverage is crucial for car dealerships to protect their business and assets from unforeseen events. Commercial property insurance, dealer insurance, and business interruption insurance play essential roles in mitigating risks and providing financial security. Commercial property insurance safeguards physical assets, while dealer insurance covers unique risks associated with car dealerships.

Business interruption insurance helps offset financial losses during periods of suspended operations. By understanding and utilizing these types of insurance, car dealerships can navigate challenges with confidence and ensure the long-term success of their business.