Best Renters Insurance in 2025 (Your Guide to the Top 10 Companies)

The best renters insurance providers are Amica, Geico, and Progressive, offering strong coverage options with rates starting at just $17 per month.

Amica stands out as the top pick overall for its exceptional customer service, high policy limits, and reliable claims support. Geico and Progressive follow closely with easy online tools and valuable bundling discounts.

Our Top 10 Company Picks: Best Renters Insurance

This guide compares the best rental insurance companies to help you find affordable protection for your personal belongings and liability insurance needs.

Looking for cheaper premiums? Enter your ZIP code to get started on finding the right provider for you and your budget.

#1 – Amica: Top Overall Pick

Pros

• Multiple Discount Options: Amica renters insurance offers a wide range of savings for autopay, loyalty, bundling, and being claims-free.
• High Customer Satisfaction: Amica is known for providing great service and regularly earns high marks in renters insurance satisfaction surveys.
• Customizable Policies: Renters can tailor Amica coverage to fit their needs, with the Amica homeowners insurance review noting its flexibility and strong service.

Cons

• Limited Availability: Amica renters insurance isn’t available in Alaska or Hawaii.
• Fewer Add-On Coverages: Offers fewer optional endorsements compared to other top rental insurance providers.

#2 – Geico: Best for Customer Service

Pros

• 24/7 Support Access: Geico offers round-the-clock customer assistance, making it easy to manage your renters insurance policy anytime.
• User-Friendly Digital Tools: The mobile app and portal simplify renters insurance tasks, as noted in the Geico homeowners insurance review.
• Quick Quote Process: Geico’s renters insurance quote system is fast, helping users compare coverage options within minutes.

Cons

• Limited In-Person Support: Geico is an online-first company and may not sit well with renters who appreciate face-to-face service.
• Inconsistent Agent Knowledge: Some users report varying service quality when calling about renters insurance details.

#3 – Progressive: Best for Comprehensive Coverage

Pros

• Flexible Coverage Options: Progressive renters insurance offers flexible renters insurance to fit your needs, as noted in the Progressive insurance review.
• User-Friendly Platform: Easy online quotes and account management make renters insurance simple to maintain.
• Add-On Protection: Available endorsements let you enhance renters insurance with identity theft, water backup, and more.

Cons

• Third-Party Underwriting: Policies are often underwritten by partners, which can lead to inconsistencies in service.
• Basic Policy Limitations: The standard renters insurance coverage might not include high-value items unless you add them.

#4 – Travelers: Best for Customizable Options

Pros

• Highly Competitive Pricing: Provides some of the most competitive rates in the industry.
• Wide Acceptance: Available in most states. See our Travelers insurance review for full details.
• High Financial Stability: Holds an A++ rating from A.M. Best.

Cons

• Limited Personalized Interaction: Some customers feel the company lacks personalized customer service.
• Conservative Discount Policies: Fewer discount opportunities compared to other major insurers.

#5 – Nationwide: Best for Smart Home Integration

Pros

• Extensive Coverage Options: Nationwide offers a broad range of coverage, including rare and unique options.
• Positive Customer Feedback: Generally receives positive reviews for customer service.
• Strong Financial Rating: Maintains an A+ rating from A.M. Best, highlighting its financial strength and reliability, as noted in our Nationwide insurance review.

Cons

• Complex Policy Structures: Some customers find their policy options complex and difficult to understand.
• Higher Cost for Additional Features: Premiums can escalate quickly with added features and coverage.

#6 – Allstate: Best for Flexible Policies

Pros

• Wide Range of Discounts: Offers a variety of discounts, including a substantial 25% for multi-vehicle policies.
• Robust Policy Options: Allstate renters insurance provides a comprehensive suite of insurance options and add-ons.
• High Customer Interaction: Known for active, accessible service, as noted in the Allstate insurance review, making it a reliable renters insurance option.

Cons

• Variable Premium Rates: Premium prices can be unpredictable, frequently based on location and other factors.
• Mixed Reviews on Claim Resolution: Some customers find issues with the speed and efficiency of claim estimation and servicing.

#7 – Liberty Mutual: Best for Affordable Rates

Pros

• Customizable Coverage: Offers highly flexible policies that can be tailored to specific needs.
• Good Discount Options: Competitive discounts, especially for safe drivers and multi-policy bundling.
• Solid Financial Standing: Rated A by A.M. Best, indicating good financial health. More information is available about this provider in our Liberty Mutual review.

Cons

• Higher Pricing Tiers: Can be more expensive than competitors, especially for basic coverage levels.
• Customer Service Variability: Some customers experience variability in service quality.

#8 – American Family: Best for Extensive Discounts

Pros

• Customer-Centric: Known for high customer satisfaction rates. Read up on the American Family insurance review & ratings.
• Broad Insurance Offerings: Provides a wide array of insurance products beyond vehicles.
• Strong Agent Network: An extensive network of agents provides personalized service.

Cons

• Availability Limitations: Not available in all states, which could limit potential customers.
• Pricing Inconsistencies: Some customers might find pricing to be higher compared to other insurers with similar offerings.

#9 – State Farm: Best for Competitive Pricing

Pros

• Bundling Discounts: Bundling policies can lead to considerable savings, as highlighted in our State Farm homeowners insurance review.
• High Coverage Flexibility: State Farm renters insurance provides many policy options to suit the needs of diverse coverage.
• Excellent Financial Rating: Holds an A++ rating from A.M. Best, indicating superior financial stability.

Cons

• Higher Premium Costs: Premiums can be slightly higher for certain coverages compared to competitors.
• Limited Multi-Policy Discount: Unlike other insurers, the average multi-policy discount available can’t be considered proven.

#10 – Farmers: Best for Claims-Free Incentives

Pros

• Strong Bundling Options: Excellent discounts for customers who bundle multiple types of insurance.
• Diverse Coverage Offerings: Provides a wide variety of coverage options to suit different needs.
• Good Customer Support: Known for accessible and supportive customer service. Unlock details in our Farmers insurance review & ratings.

Cons

• Inconsistent Agent Experience: Customer experiences can vary significantly depending on the individual agent.
• Premium Costs: Some policies may come at a higher cost compared to industry averages.

Monthly Car Insurance Rates for Renters by Provider

The cost of car insurance for renters is based on the monthly rates offered by various insurers for minimum and full coverage. This section dives into those rates to help renters make educated decisions.

Renters Insurance Monthly Rates by Provider & Deductible

Compare monthly renters insurance rates by provider and deductible level to find the best value for your needs. State Farm offers some of the lowest rates overall, starting at just $10 per month with a $2,000 deductible.

Amica and Geico also provide competitive pricing, along with strong coverage, dependable customer service, and useful policy features that make them excellent choices for renters seeking both affordability and protection.

Top Insurance Discounts for Renters by Provider & Savings

Top insurance providers offer valuable renters discounts for claims-free history, security systems, loyalty, and AutoPay, helping you lower your monthly premium.

Learn more in our “Toggle Renters Insurance Review & Ratings.”

Renters Insurance Coverage Options

Renters insurance works like a homeowners policy but does not cover the structure of your home. That part is handled by your landlord’s insurance. Even the cheapest renters insurance can protect your belongings, liability, and living expenses if something goes wrong.

• Personal Property Damage Coverage: Protects your belongings like furniture, electronics, and clothing if damaged or destroyed by events such as fire, theft, or vandalism.
• Personal Liability Coverage: Covers legal expenses and damages if you’re held responsible for injuring someone or damaging their property, either in your rental or elsewhere.
• Medical Payments Coverage: Pays for medical expenses if a guest is injured in your rental, regardless of who is at fault; it typically does not cover residents or household members.
• Additional Living Expenses Coverage: Helps pay for temporary housing, food, and other necessary costs if your rental becomes uninhabitable due to a covered event like a fire or major water damage.

Renters insurance focuses on you, your personal belongings, potential legal fees, and living expenses.

Most renters policies offer coverage for personal property damage, personal liability, medical payments, and additional living expenses. Protecting yourself and your belongings is why you need renters insurance.

Renters Insurance Coverage Exclusions

Renters insurance provides several key protections, but it’s worth noting what it does not cover. Most standard policies don’t cover certain situations like damage from earthquakes and floods, loss of a roommate’s personal property, infestations like bed bugs and other pests, and theft or damage to your car.

Knowing about these exclusions will help you make the best decisions for your situation and avoid surprises when it’s time to file a claim. Delve into our evaluation of “Home Preparedness – What to Do in an Earthquake.”

Fortunately, renters insurance is typically very affordable. Policies can cost as little as $10 per month, with the average cost in the U.S. around $14 per month. However, rates can differ depending on a variety of factors, such as where you live, how much coverage you want, your deductible, and even your credit score.

For example, people with lower credit scores often face higher premiums. Because of this, it’s essential to compare quotes from multiple providers before selecting a policy. Doing so ensures you’re getting the best coverage for your needs at the most competitive rate.

How to Choose the Best Renters Insurance Policy

Most companies offer an easy application process for people looking for renters insurance. To find the best renters insurance for you, try the following tips:

• Determine Your Coverage Needs: Making a basic inventory of your belongings will help you determine how much coverage you need. Most renters policies start with $30,000 worth of personal belongings coverage, so you might need to buy more.
• Pick Your Coverage: If you live in an area without earthquake or flood risks, you’ll probably be fine with a standard policy. A representative can review your options to help you find the perfect policy.
• Compare Your Options: Comparing multiple companies is the best way to get the best coverage for your home. Some companies have cheaper rates, but better coverage is sometimes worth paying more for.

Once you know where you want to buy a policy from, applying for coverage is usually a simple task. Most companies offer online application options that you can complete in about 10 minutes.

If you prefer not to fill out a digital application, you can also speak with a representative over the phone or in person. Access comprehensive insights into our “Nationwide vs. Grange Insurance Renters Insurance.”

How to Save on Renters Insurance

Renters insurance is already affordable, but there are still ways to save. Whether you are new to renting or reviewing your policy, these tips can help lower your monthly cost without losing important coverage.

• Bundle With Other Policies: Combine renters insurance with auto or other policies to unlock discounts of up to 25% from providers like Geico, Progressive, and Allstate.
• Raise Your Deductible: A higher deductible can lower your premium, and your insurance agent’s role in the claims process helps you prepare for what you might pay.
• Improve Home Safety: Install smoke detectors, deadbolts, or a home security system. Many insurers offer discounts for added security—some even for living in a gated complex or a building with sprinklers.
• Pay Annually Instead of Monthly: Paying your premium in one lump sum each year can help you avoid installment fees and unlock a discount with certain providers.
• Maintain a Claims-Free Record: Staying claim-free for a few years can qualify you for a loyalty or claims-free discount, which rewards careful renters and long-term customers.

A little effort goes a long way when it comes to saving on renters insurance. From bundling policies to making your home safer, these tips can help you keep more money in your pocket while still giving you peace of mind.

Before locking in a policy, compare quotes from multiple providers to make sure you’re getting the best value for your needs.

Find the Best Renters Insurance Today

The best renters insurance providers are offered by Amica, Geico, and Progressive, offering reliable coverage starting at just $22 per month. These top companies offer competitive prices and excellent customer support, plus additional perks such as bundle discounts and helpful online tools.

With affordable rates and solid coverage, top renters insurance providers make it easy to protect your belongings and liability. As more Americans rent, having the right policy is essential, and with low monthly costs, it’s a smart and valuable investment.

Even though renters insurance is affordable, you should always compare your options. From finding the right coverage to getting the best price, comparing policies between companies is the best way to get the right insurance for your home. Discover more about offerings in our “Best Renters Insurance for Families.”

Enter your ZIP code below to compare rates from the top providers near you.